Return on Investment - Tub vs. Shower
July 24, 2025

Whether to have a bathtub or a shower ultimately comes down to a personal decision. If you are making the decision as a resale investment, research supports both arguments. One source reports that bathtubs are more beneficial in increasing the value of your home as the market views them as more valuable fixtures. Many US homeowners recoup around 60% of their investment from having a bathtub installed. Advice from real estate agents around the country is to have at least one bathtub in your home. Bathtubs paired with showers are more attractive to prospective homebuyers than a bathtub by itself.
In the perennial debate over tub vs. shower resale value, a different source touts that showers emerge as the frontrunner in today’s real estate market. Their space-saving design, accessibility features, and alignment with modern lifestyle preferences make them a wise investment for homeowners looking to boost their property’s value. There are pros and cons to either decision.
Advantages Of Installing A Shower
- Most standard-sized showers require approximately 9 square feet, compared to the standard bathtub, which occupies 13 square feet.
- Showers require less plumbing.
- They can be installed in a variety of locations, which makes them ideal for small bathrooms.
- Showers can be taken at any temperature, on average using about 30 gallons of water, making them a more energy-efficient option.
- Showers are more accessible for those with disabilities. Non-slip tiles and grab bars can help to prevent accidents, while benches can provide a place to rest.
Advantages Of Installing A Bathtub
- Bathtubs are potentially less expensive to install.
- Many families view bathtubs as being safer for kids.
- A hot bath can help to relieve muscle pain, improve sleep quality, and even reduce stress levels.
- Spending time in a warm tub can also help to fight off colds and respiratory infections.
These are just a few of the factors to consider when deciding to remodel a bathroom. Trends can change quickly, and what was once considered a valuable feature could suddenly become less desirable.